flag de flag gb flag fr
Legal notice     European Milk Board ASBL | Rue de la Loi 155 | B-1040 Bruxelles

News Details

PDF-Icon Icon-Print

14.07.2017

Sale of milk powder from intervention prevents milk price recovery

The European Milk Board calls on Agriculture Commissioner Hogan to stop selling storage stocks at junk prices

(Brussels, 14 July 2017) On June 20, the European Commission approved the sale of a further 100 tons of skimmed milk powder from public intervention storage at a price of €185/100kg. According to the European Milk Board, these sales at below-value prices negatively affect the European and international dairy market. Furthermore, this action clearly contradicts the European Commission's own statement: that selling at all costs was never an option for the Commission and that the maintenance of market balance and price recovery remained its main objectives.

Romuald Schaber, President of the European Milk Board, is dismayed by this sale of intervention milk powder: "This is a stab in the back for Europe's milk producers and a devastating sign to other actors in the dairy market. Milk buyers are free to continue speculating with cheap powder." He added that milk prices, which are slowly recovering, will end up being suppressed again.

Milk powder from intervention should only be sold at a price that would not undermine price stability. Starting with production costs of over 40 cents per litre of raw milk, which is the case in countries with a high degree of intervention like France, Germany and Belgium, and adding transport, processing and marketing costs, we arrive at a price threshold of at least 335 euros/100kg milk powder. In order to reduce the enormous powder stocks of about 350,000 tons, other sales channels could be considered, for example, its use as animal feed.

"The Commission should learn from past mistakes and finally understand that intervention cannot bring sufficient stability to the dairy market," continues Schaber. If milk prices remain at the current low levels, dairy farmers will continue to produce milk in order to prop up their cash flow and storage will continue to fill up. The past has also shown that only the EU volume reduction programme had a real effect on milk prices because it directly attacked the issue of overproduction. The EU would be well-advised to implement volume reduction instruments in a timely fashion in the future, instead of simply taking surpluses of the market temporarily and thus delaying a real solution to the problem.

After Agriculture Commissioner Hogan trivialised the problem of skimmed milk powder stocks and pointed to historically high fat prices, the European Milk Board has addressed the Commissioner directly in a letter sent out yesterday: “It is important to look at how SMP sold at junk prices affects farm-gate price. You are aware that it has a problematic effect, as the milk price is put under pressure and a price recovery is blocked. By putting such cheap milk powder on the market, you are also indicating that high value creation and fair prices in the dairy sector are, at the end of the day, of little concern to you. This does nothing to help the ongoing debate on fairness and sustainability in agriculture… You will realise that the high fat prices are sadly not sufficiently reflected in producer prices. Fat accounts for only half of the milk price; protein, i.e. milk powder, the other half. For milk prices to rise, it is therefore important to have an appropriate price for milk powder as well.”

The letter to Agriculture Commissioner Hogan also clearly states that the sale of skimmed milk powder at junk prices acts as a burden on the international dairy market and that if this practice were to continue, the European Milk Board would have to consider a legal review of the same.

 

Contacts:

EMB President Romuald Schaber (DE): +49 (0)160 352 4703
EMB Managing Director Silvia Däberitz (DE, EN, FR): +32 (0)2808 1936


More News

10.10.2018

Milk cost study shows: There is a gap between production costs and producer prices

Overview published with the latest figures from France, Germany, Denmark, Belgium, Luxembourg and the Netherlands

20.09.2018

Milk strike 2009 - Nine years and counting!

Milk strikes were and continue to be the only radical solution to obtain cost-covering milk prices (45 cents per litre). This was a way for us to show our solidarity in the face of technocrats, politicians, the dairy industry and cooperatives. We saw it as an investment in a better future for milk production. The strike did...

14.09.2018

Newsletter September online!

The whole of Europe suffered consequences of this summer's drought. The dry weather affected pastures, hay and silage as well as cereal and straw production. As a result of the drought, milk producers are missing key, self-produced feed. Read more

07.09.2018

Irish dairy farmers feel financial squeeze from drought

September on Irish dairy farms would normally be a time when we would be enjoying the fruits of our Summer and preparing for the Autumn and Winter ahead. Bills incurred during the Spring would be paid and farmers would look with pride and reassurance on high rows of bales and full silage pits. The long winter of 2017/18 meant...

22.08.2018
16.08.2018

Newsletter August online!

I am greatly concerned to see how Europe is currently facing significant pressure – nationalistic forces internally and divisive motivations externally. I am convinced that there will only be losers if this very dangerous situation were to become even worse. Read more

19.07.2018

Study shows success of the EU volume reduction scheme announced 2 years ago

(Brussels, 19.07.2018) Two years ago – on 18 July 2016 – European Commissioner for Agriculture Phil Hogan announced the EU volume reduction scheme for the dairy market. The measure was a great success and showed that even small reductions have a major effect on producer prices. A study by A. Fink-Keßler and A. Trouvé examined...