flag de flag gb flag fr
Legal notice     European Milk Board ASBL | Rue de la Loi 155 | B-1040 Bruxelles

News Details

PDF-Icon Icon-Print


Successful crisis management in the EU – What are the lessons to be learnt from the last three years?

(Berlin, 18 January 2018): That a crisis measure is not a crisis measure in and of itself has been clearly demonstrated in the dairy sector in the last three years. As the Executive Committee of the European Milk Board summarised at this year's Green Week press conference, truly effective instruments must be implemented in the future.

The European Commission has taken action over the last few years to temper the dramatic effects of market liberalisation: Aid packages to the tune of millions were introduced, thresholds for intervention volumes were raised, and producer organisations and dairies were given the possibility of product planning. However, the implemented crisis measures had little effect and producers continued to be forced to produce more milk to prop up their cash flow on the basis of higher production volumes. It was only the implementation of the volume reduction programme, where producers could voluntarily scale down their production, that finally brought about a turnaround.


What are the concrete lessons to be learnt?

  • According to EMB president Romuald Schaber, Agriculture Commissioner Phil Hogan hit the bullseye after a number of failed attempts with the EU volume reduction programme: "We need the right measures. The reduction programme addressed volume and had a substantial effect on prices thanks to a small reduction in delivery volume." He went on to explain that the programme contributed significantly to price recovery from 25.68 cents/litre (July 2016) to 34.16 cents (July 2017) and its implementation was not bureaucratic for milk producers.

    In addition, continued Schaber, a scientific analysis of the EU volume reduction programme (Fink-Keßler and Trouvé, 2017) also shows that the measure could be effectively used to keep farms in business using small reductions and could provide direct support to farms during crises. 
  • The intervention measure in particular was definitely overextended in the past and simply ended up as a way to catch the spill over of liberalised production. Public intervention is as such a tried and tested instrument to absorb seasonal surpluses, says Sieta van Keimpema, vice president of the European Milk Board. "But the fact that the European Commission is now sitting on almost 380,000 tons of skimmed milk powder, for which it has no plan, shows that this instrument has been implemented in a completely faulty fashion this time around." In the case of a market imbalance, EU policies should not simply prolong the situation by taking intervention milk off the market in the short-term and leaving it to become a burden further on. "There must be incentives to not produce so much in the first place," says van Keimpema. She believes that this would diffuse looming crises.


The European Milk Board calls for the implementation of effective crisis instruments and the legal anchoring of a milk volume reduction programme during crises. The dairy farmer's association points to its Market Responsibility Programme, which is built on voluntary production cuts and production caps during the reduction period.

Producers can thus react to market signals and adapt their production accordingly as soon as the market balance is disturbed.

Here you will find pictures of the EMB presse conference




EMB president Romuald Schaber (DE): +49 (0)160 352 4703

EMB vice president Sieta van Keimpema (DE, NL, EN): +31 (0)6 12 16 80 00

EMB managing director Silvia Däberitz (DE, EN, FR): +32 (0)2808 1936



More News


4000 km and 6 days in the bus there and back: "Dear heads of state, there needs to be fairness in the Common Agricultural Policy at last!"

Baltic producers call for an alignment of direct payments today in Brussels The European Milk Board urges for an efficient crisis instrument for the milk market


Baltic milk producers together with EMB call on heads of state and government to establish fair EU conditions

Invitation to press interviews and milk producer rally on 13 December 2018 in Brussels


Newsletter November/December online!

In solidarity and with one voice The associations of the European Milk Board (EMB) held their Members' Assembly in the Black Forest ten days ago, where they discussed the current situation. Read more


What's the matter with the dairy sector?

2013 – 2018: Realistic cost studies illustrate the true situation on the dairy market in the last 5 years


European farmers show solidarity and speak with one voice:

"We call for a responsible dairy policy and an effective structure for the Common Agricultural Policy of the EU"


Newsletter October online!

What is the cost of producing milk? In our sector, numerous spokespersons have the bad habit of taking the milk price as a starting point for looking at the dairy market. A short-sighted vision, because for dairy farmers the cost of production is as important as farm gate prices. In economic terms, it is impossible to consider...


Milk production costs still not covered in Germany

(Brussels, 15/10/2018) The quarterly cost figures for Germany show that only 80% of production costs were covered in July 2018, while in April it was 78% and 88% in January. Production costs in July amounted to 43.28 cents; however, producers only received 34.56 cents for their product.Milk prices and production costs are still...